Fire stations are unique among civic buildings in that many communities have not just one, but multiple. And as municipalities grow, so does their need for this critical service, making the addition of new stations something that can be anticipated and mapped out well in advance. Similarly, well-established communities can forecast facility upgrades to replace aging, outdated fire service buildings.

Scenarios like these, where a community is looking at building several new stations over a defined period, are ideal situations to create a prototype design for use across multiple projects.

How Prototyping Works

In a prototype scenario, the architectural team works with the department to create a floor plan that, with minimal adjustments, can be implemented across multiple sites, even if they are developed years apart. Each station must be tailored to meet the physical constraints of its specific parcel, including locations of utility connections, topography and stormwater management areas, and curb cuts. Despite these nuances, a well-designed prototype can accommodate the differences each site presents.

The Prototyping Payoff

When a department considers developing a prototype, cost savings are usually top of mind. And it’s true a prototype often results in efficiencies: After the initial investment, the architecture and design fees to adapt that design for subsequent sites will be significantly less than starting from scratch. Furthermore, constructing the design the first time will help identify issues that always arise during construction, creating additional savings during subsequent builds.

Beyond these savings, the biggest financial benefit of a prototype is providing predictability in cost parameters. That’s not to say a prototype built today will cost the same to construct several years from now, but departments with a model in place have a baseline of what to expect from a planning and fundraising perspective.

Operationally, prototype design creates continuity from station to station; no one location is clearly a better place to work, which is a positive for recruitment and morale. Standardizing spaces also aids in training and seamless staff movement between department stations, even if team members haven’t worked there before.

Finally, similarities in building systems allow maintenance crews to build a department-wide knowledge of these mechanicals, so they are better equipped to handle maintenance and repairs and can use interchangeable parts across stations.

Design Considerations

While a prototype creates a standardized design, there are always some changes made between sites — whether for aesthetic, operational or location-specific reasons.

For example, many municipalities using a prototype want to vary each facility’s exterior to create visual interest and reflect its location. This can be done by varying roof lines, cladding and architectural details, as demonstrated by three stations built from a BKV Group-designed prototype in Henrico County, Va. While they have nearly identical layouts, Short Pump Firehouse 19 reflects the materiality and rooflines of the surrounding residential neighborhood with siding and manufactured stone; Staples Mill Firehouse 20 takes cues from the County Campus in which it sits, with red brick and tan accents; and Bungalow City Firehouse 23, located in a historic part of the county, has a more traditional exterior featuring brick with limestone accents and arched openings.

Sometimes departments require small changes between prototype stations to accommodate unique conditions. That could be switching out a training room with a community room for a station with more public interaction, or adding an extra apparatus bay for a company that also does technical rescue. While some prototype changes might have implications for how the station fits on the site, or require rearranging or resizing floor plan elements, special situations can generally be accommodated.

The site also dictates changes made to a prototype, including to systems and mechanicals. Spotsylvania County, Va., adapted a prototype to two extremely different parcels. Company 12, in Massaponax, is on a flat site next to industrial uses and served by sewer, water, three-phase power, and natural gas lines. Company 3, in rural Partlow, required a well and storage tank for domestic water, a larger water tank to serve the fire protection system, and propane tanks for heating and cooking. The takeaway is that very rarely can a prototype be rubber stamped from site to site, but the level of adjustments is manageable.

Creating a prototype is an upfront investment for all parties involved. But working with an architect to make important decisions about department-wide priorities for building organization, features and amenities pays off in the long run with consistent, well-planned facilities aligned with the needs of the team both today and years into the future.

Craig Carter, AIA, LEED AP BD+C, is the Fire/EMS Practice Leader, Partner and firematic expert with BKV Group, which is a full-service design firm that has offices around the country. Carter has 24 years of experience in architectural design, documentation and construction administration with a focus on public safety projects. He has worked on more than 170 fire station projects and won several design awards that celebrate the functionality and beauty of the projects. Carter combines a deep knowledge of the history of public-sector design with an up-to-date knowledge of the latest national trends.

Mark Manetti, Government Managing Partner at BKV Group, has over 25 years of experience managing projects for different government agencies. He has worked on multiple public facilities including public safety, library and recreation centers. In addition, many of the projects Manetti has developed have had historic significance and jurisdictional purview through local historic boards and regional groups such as the District historic preservation office (HPO) the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO), and the National Capital Planning Commission (NCPC). Manetti works closely with his clients to document their standard workflows and to translate those into an appropriate building program. He is an advocate for resiliency in government projects and has in-depth knowledge of applying sustainable standards to public facilities, approaching projects with focus and a sense of urgency that promotes decision-making and moves schedules forward.